corsia logo

Truckers vs California Independent Contractor Law

Truckers vs California Independent Contractor Law

Compromise lies at the heart of any relationship between businesses, workers, and the state. Regardless of how much we dislike it, we understand there is no avoiding it. However, it is a tough balancing act, especially when you don’t even know where the balance is. And it gets even worse when states try to solve issues in one broad swoop.

Last year we got another example of how generalized solutions can disrupt entire businesses. This time, the issue revolves around California Assembly Bill 5, which sets the California Independent Contractor Law.

At the surface level, this law seems to solve a lot of problems for employees and contractors. It should put an end to certain bad practices in some industries. Why all the fuss about it then? Because its consequences go way beyond its intended use. Let’s explore that in more depth!

What is the California Independent Contractor Law?

In September 2019, the California Assembly Bill 5 was finally passed, putting the law into effect with the start of 2020. That said, talks about it have been happening for at least two years before that. This legislation is an attempt to safeguard workers against dishonest corporate practices, which have been going for a while.

Since independent contractors don’t count as employees, companies have to only pay them for the services such workers provide. Anything else – sick leave, paid time-off, or retirement plan, among other benefits – does not apply to a contractor.

This is all fine if it works as intended. Say I am providing your business with my services as a business-to-business relationship. Perhaps you are an IT firm that needs some electrical or plumbing work done. As an independent contractor, i.e. a self-employed worker, I can offer you my services. You pay my fee, and it’s up to me to care for my own benefits. At least, this is how the system should work.

Unfortunately, certain industries have started to exploit that. The IT sector, for example, has gained notoriety for hiring workers as independent contractors. Not to do the plumbing, mind you, but to carry out the very work of the business. In other words, companies could avoid paying employee benefits by listing workers as independent contractors.

It should be obvious that such practices hurt workers. This is especially hard if your niche is competitive, and you are virtually forced to work under such conditions. This is what the California Independent Contractor Law wanted to fix. Sadly, it may have actually caused issues of its own!

Does the law solve anything?

All regulations that affect the workflow of businesses eventually face controversy. However, as Assembly Bill 5 targets the entire gig economy, the backlash has been even more severe. Interestingly, it has come both from companies and individuals alike.

For starters, let us see how the law attempts to fix the issue. The legislators have come up with 3 criteria, which should point us to whether a worker could be classified as independent. Here they are:

  1. Independent contractors should only carry out tasks that are not directly related to the work of the business. For example, an IT company cannot hire an independent contractor as a programmer.
  2. Independent contractors should operate as such outside of their relationship with the given business. If an IT company wants a plumber to work for it all day, every day, the plumber should be classified as an employee now.
  3. Companies cannot direct or control independent contractors. They can hire a contractor for a job, but not tell them how to execute it, neither control them in any way. Otherwise, the worker should be classified as an employee.

This all seems reasonable, but does it work? In certain situations, it does. However, many workers like the flexibility that comes with being an independent contractor. Now they can no longer do so. On top of that, the law fails entirely within certain sectors. The most notable example is the trucking industry!

Truckers vs California Independent Contractor Law

What does the law mean for the trucking industry? With the recent ELD mandate deadline, and now the passing of Assembly Bill 5, the trucking industry has plenty of legislation to process. In that regard, most people think the AB5 specifically is not only unnecessary for the industry but also harmful. How so?

Let me first point out that the law is not all bad and solves certain issues. Yet, they only apply to truckers who do very specific jobs, and only them (e.g. port truckers).

On the other hand, interstate carriers and truckers, in general, do not see why the law should affect them. Many truck drivers prefer to act as owner-operators for various reasons, but the regulation will now hinder them.

This is a unique situation because concerns are raised by both big companies and independent workers alike. Carriers prefer the option of hiring independent truckers when the demand necessitates it. However, if the businesses have to keep them on constant payroll, logistics services will arbitrarily become more expensive.

Many have also pointed out that the law tries to fix things that were never broken in the first place. It can limit truckers’ employment in general and worsen their situation. No one – neither carriers nor the drivers themselves – wants that.

Fortunately, the most recent developments show a way out of this mess. The California Trucking Association (CTA) managed to get a preliminary injunction after a court hearing on January 13th. Although the road ahead is still unclear, the trucking industry has the potential to be exempt from this law. The final decision will be worked out in a lawsuit filed by CTA.

What do you think about the California Independent Contractor Law?

Obviously, certain regulations are necessary to keep all parties in check. Everyone can agree that exploiting workers, especially when they have no other option, is not ethical. Yet it is also not exactly clear where we should draw the line.

As a car shipping company, we from Corsia Logistics pay close attention to such regulations. We do our best to present the situation as objectively as possible, so we also want to hear from you.

What do you think about the law? Are truckers right to protest it, or should we change the way our industry operates as a whole? In any case, we will keep an eye out for any developments!

Share our experience:
Are you ready to ship a car?
Recent posts
car shipping quote

Truckers Can Fight Sex Trafficking

If You See Something, Say Something! This is the slogan of the nonprofit group Truckers Against Trafficking, the organization’s main goal is to have more

Shipping a Rivian

Shipping a Rivian

Shipping an electric vehicle like Rivian requires several considerations. Here we will share some key aspects to keep in mind when you need to ship

Read more

Corsia Logistics team works hard every day to ensure reliable expedited car shipping service. Our customer reviews prove that.

5-Star Rated Car Shipping Company


they trusted us

and here's what they say

Simon Moore
Great company
Read More
Looking for a logistics company, to ship my car, from California to Illinois,my first search, then Corsia showed up, skeptical. Call and a very friendly secretary: Elena. She guided me through, I scheduled and as she explained, all when smooth as scheduled Very happy I did the right choice. I'll recommend this great Company to anyone that is thinking to relocate a vehicle. Thanks Corsia logistics for your honesty and professionalism!
Elizabeth Woodward
High five's all around!
Read More
Corsia was highly recommended by a friend in the automobile industry. We needed to transport a cargo van from Seattle to Florida. We contacted Corsia who quickly arranged transport within just a few days. Communication was outstanding! Just a few email confirmations and we were all set. Mike was great and arrived right on time and delivered to Florida on schedule. Tip-avoid the hornets nest of auto brokers on line and just contact Corsia for a truly great experience!
Carrol Tiffany
Read More
Corsia has been amazing. Their prices are really competitive but more importantly their customer service has been 5-Star. Elena followed up with me every step of the way, making sure there was no miscommunication between me & the driver. We are using them to ship a 2nd vehicle & would not hesitate to use them again!
Tony Boyd
Definitely recommend
Read More
I have recently used Corsia for long time family car with sentimental value that was moved I have recently used Corsia for shipment of my vehicle from Oregon to Arizona by recommendation from other family member who also used Corsia in the past. I am very pleased on the service and the communication throughout shipment. Ken was my direct contact and kept me informed along the move The car was picked up and delivered as communicated. I did use a enclosed mover and the driver was also clean cut professional and treated car as his own. I would definitely recommend Corsia again with the experience I have had. Thank you. T
Top notch
Read More
Top notch Transport - Porsche 997 Top notch! As easy and efficient as one could possibly imagine. Great customer service.. thank you Luke. Great prices. Check. Timely communications. Check. Clean transport trailer. Check. Supremely careful driver. Check. Timely arrival. Check. Don't mess around elsewhere, just call Corsica and feel confident your transports needs are going to be exceeded. My Porsche 911 rode like a Queen in her enclosed chariot. I've never needed a transport company before, and I surely will use them every time. Do yourself a favor, seriously. Call now.
Geet Mp Haryana
Reliable, efficient
Read More
Corsia rep (Elena) was very proactive. Helped ship a car from CA to GA. She checked in with me via email quote and several phone calls to find me the best possible quote for the fastest available service. After several communications, Corsia was able to schedule a vehicle pickup the next day. The driver communicated well, and the vehicle arrived in final destination faster than we expected in perfect condition. I highly recommend using Corsia's reliable, efficient service.
Cay Liptak
Clean, efficient, wonderful
Read More
Thanks, Corsia! Pickup was so clean, efficient, and wonderful -- my only recommendation is to make sure you schedule it during the day so you can fully review the car in the daylight. Drop off was equally wonderful, and the whole trip went down without a hitch (pun intended!). Seriously, Corsia delivered my Jeep from CT to California with no issues or bumps in the road!
Csaba Kovesdy
Truly positive experience
Read More
Corsia Memphis to LA, mid-size SUV. I looked at 4 different companies amd Corsia was the most responsive of them. While being responsive, they were not unduly aggressive: when I indicated that I need to wait a month before making a decision they stopped contacting me and only came back with a reminder when I really needed it. Once I decided to engage Corsia they found me a transport within two days and the car was delivered (from Memphis to LA) in another two days. I had a truly positive experience.
Kelly Torres
Highly recommend
Read More
Working with Corsia Logistics was a great experience. Working with Corsia Logistics was wonderful. They were able to find a driver right away to transport our car. They were in constant communication as to when the car was getting picked up and dropped off. The driver also communicated with me as to when he would arrive. I would highly recommend Corsia Logistics.
Amy Nelson
Excellent Organization
Read More
Corsia was an excellent company to work with while I transferred my car across the US. A friend of mine suggested I use them as they had been very organized and trustworthy with her own car. I researched a few different place but decided to go with Corsia and I'm so glad I did! Any questions I had throughout the process they answered quickly and clearly. I would definitely use them again in the future and recommend them for others to use.